Before we dive into our final thoughts on A Curse of Shadows and Ice by Catharina Maura, don’t forget that our January Bite Me Box featuring Heavenly Bodies by Imani Erriu is still available. If you love fantasy romance filled with tension, magic, and emotionally rich storytelling, this box is one you don’t want to miss.
Shop the January Bite Me Box here.
Welcome to the Final Week of Our A Curse of Shadows and Ice Read Along
Welcome back to our fourth and final week of the A Curse of Shadows and Ice read along. Catharina Maura did an excellent job tapping into my emotions this week (and no, we’re not blaming hormones—absolutely not).
Let’s start in the best place, shall we?
A Romance That Delivers the Happily Ever After
It ends in a happily ever after. As much as we all knew it would, I still love sitting in this moment because it’s such a key requirement of romance—especially romantasy. I could absolutely go on a rant about how romance novels must include a HEA or at least a happy-for-now ending, but I’ll spare you that particular soapbox today.
This ending mirrored the original Beauty and the Beast beautifully. Arabella returning home before choosing to return to Felix—and sacrificing the life she once desperately wanted back—worked perfectly. It felt earned, layered, and emotionally satisfying.
Pythia, Predictions, and a Well-Placed Twist
Catharina Maura did surprise me with Pythia. I began to suspect her early in this final section; her prophecies felt too focused on pushing Felix away from Arabella, particularly by showing her with Nathaniel.
As we saw, though, those visions didn’t pull Arabella toward Nathaniel—they pushed him away entirely. (You know…the thing I’ve been saying for the last three weeks.)
My suspicions were correct, but I love that I didn’t fully connect the dots until late in the game. That slow reveal is exactly the kind of structural build that made A Curse of Shadows and Ice work so well.
Her stepping out of the mirror and becoming the true sacrifice? Loved it.
Family, Forgiveness, and Emotional Closure
I was also genuinely happy that Felix got his moment of connection with his mother in the end. The fact that he’s still deeply affected by it afterward felt incredibly real. After more than a century of resentment and grief, there’s no reason he should suddenly be okay—and I’m glad the story honored that.
Arabella’s return home was just as satisfying. Her defying her father, stripping him of his title after he attempted to imprison her again, and helping guide her sister into becoming the right kind of monarch gave her old life real closure. That arc was handled beautifully.
A Strong Story Held Back by Editing Issues
Now…here’s where I struggle.
Once again, I’m genuinely flabbergasted by how much editing this book still needed—especially considering it went from a self-published TikTok sensation to a traditionally published title. Did they just slap on a new cover and call it a day?
Editors, where were you?
The repetitive phrasing, the stilted sections, the moments that could have been so easily tightened or corrected—it’s frustrating. Because the storytelling was there. The character development was there. The voice was mostly there.
This could have been exceptional. And instead, it landed somewhere just shy of that. A major miss on Hachette’s part, in my opinion. (If your editors are overloaded, hire more of them. Truly.)
Looking Ahead: Elaine, Raphael, and Book Two
With that rant out of the way—let’s talk about Elaine.
Poor Elaine. This was an excellent setup for book two with her and Raphael, and yes, I’ll probably read it. Second-chance romances are some of my favorites, and I’m genuinely curious to see how her story unfolds next.
Final Thoughts on A Curse of Shadows and Ice
Overall, A Curse of Shadows and Ice by Catharina Maura delivered a satisfying romantasy arc with strong emotional payoff, an effective slow burn, and a romance that earned its happily ever after—even if the execution could have been cleaner.
Let me know your final thoughts in the comments. Did the ending work for you? Were you as suspicious of Pythia as I was?
Next week, we’re starting Nocticadia by Keri Lake, reading up to Chapter 19. This one is a chonker, so buckle in.
Until then—happy reading!
Leave a Reply